Story

Proposal: Cookie Consent Should Be Browser-Native, Not Website-Native

zak-mandhro Monday, April 21, 2025

TL;DR: Cookie consent shouldn’t be a popup war on every website. Browsers should handle it natively — just like location or notifications — based on user-set privacy preferences. We can fix the web with one header, a little browser enforcement, and a lot less nonsense.

The current system for cookie consent is a mess. Every website throws a popup in your face, asking you to accept tracking you neither want nor need. The irony? It’s not technically necessary. We can solve it at the browser level — cleanly, universally, and in a user-respecting way.

Here’s how:

1. Browser-Level Privacy Preferences Browsers should allow users to set global consent preferences, just like setting a default language or search engine.

Example:

* Essential cookies: Always allow

* Analytics cookies: Ask or Block

* Marketing cookies: Ask or Block

* Third-party cookies: Ask or Block

Set once. Apply everywhere. No more popups.

2. New HTTP Header: Set-Cookie-Category Websites would categorize cookies when setting them, like:

Set-Cookie: sessionId=abc123; Category=Essential Set-Cookie: trackUser=true; Category=Marketing

Standardized categories: Essential, Analytics, Marketing, Personalization, Other. No trickery. No ambiguity.

3. Browser Enforcement When a site tries to set a cookie:

* Browser checks the declared category.

* Browser checks the user's privacy preferences.

* If no consent: cookie is silently blocked.

If consent is "Ask," the browser shows a small permission prompt (similar to location or notifications). No more hijacking the page UI.

1. Optional Website Messaging Websites could optionally trigger a browser-native dialog to explain their cookie use — but no walls of legalese blocking access.

2. Bonus: Easier Compliance Audits Browsers could expose APIs for compliance tools to automatically verify if a site respects consent preferences.

Why hasn’t this happened yet?

* Ad-tech companies make too much money off friction and dark patterns.

* Browser vendors (especially Chrome) profit from the status quo.

* Regulators targeted websites, not browsers, in GDPR/CCPA drafts.

But it’s not too late. Safari, Firefox, Brave, Arc — even Chrome (if enough pressure builds) — could easily implement this.

Users deserve better. The web deserves better.

If you think this should be built, upvotes help visibility.

15 12
Read on Hacker News Comments 12